A photographer's Mac fills predictably, and it is fixable by workflow
Where the space goes in a photo workflow, which parts are derived, and a setup that keeps the internal drive usable.
Photography fills a Mac in a predictable order: originals, then previews, then exports, then the copies that exist because two applications each wanted their own. Only the first of those is irreplaceable, which is what makes this fixable.
Where it goes
| What | Share of the total | Replaceable |
|---|---|---|
| RAW originals | Usually the largest | No |
| Previews and smart previews | Can exceed the originals | Yes, rebuilt |
| Catalog and database | Small | No, it is your edits |
| Exports and web versions | Grows quietly | Yes, re-export |
| Duplicate imports | Pure waste | Yes |
The setup that works
- Originals on an external drive, organised by date, with a second copy somewhere else.
- Catalog on the internal drive, because it is small and constantly written to.
- Previews sized to your screen rather than 1:1 for everything, and set to discard after 30 days, per Lightroom previews.
- Exports treated as disposable, deleted after delivery.
- One library, not two, because a Photos library and a Lightroom catalog holding the same images is two copies.
The Photos and Lightroom overlap
Many photographers end up with images in both, because a phone syncs into Photos and a camera imports into Lightroom. That is two complete copies of anything shot on both. Deciding which one owns which images, once, is worth more than any cleanup, and what the Photos library holds covers its side.
Culling is the only real answer to originals
Previews rebuild and exports re-export, so the only category that grows without limit is originals. A culling pass at import, deleting the obvious failures before they are ever backed up, compounds over years in a way no cleanup does.
What to check when the disk fills anyway
du -sh ~/Pictures/* 2>/dev/null | sort -h | tail
find ~/Pictures -name '*Previews.lrdata' -exec du -sh {} + 2>/dev/null
du -sh ~/Pictures/*.photoslibrary 2>/dev/nullNine times out of ten the answer is previews or a second library, both of which are dealt with in an afternoon. If the answer is genuinely originals, what moves safely to an external drive is the next step.
Common questions
What uses the most space in a photo workflow?
RAW originals, followed by previews, which on a large catalog can exceed the originals themselves. Exports and duplicate imports across two applications make up most of the rest.
Should my photo library be on an external drive?
Originals, yes, with a second copy elsewhere. The catalog is small and written to constantly, so it belongs on the internal drive for speed.
Why do I have the same photos twice?
Usually because a phone syncs into Photos while a camera imports into Lightroom, so anything shot on both exists in two libraries. Deciding which library owns which images resolves it permanently.
How do I stop a photo library growing forever?
Cull at import, set previews to be discarded after a month, and treat exports as disposable. Originals are the only category that cannot be regenerated, so they are the only one worth keeping indefinitely.